The Whitby Hotel

Beautiful decoration in the rooms. The bar and restaurant were fantastic for both after-work drinks and breakfasts. The bathrooms were top quality (particularly in the restaurant!). Although you're minutes from Central Park and other major attractions, the hotel feels like a world away. So quiet and peaceful!

Accessing the wifi could have been easier. It wasn't made clear from the check-in process or room information how we were supposed to access it. The climate controls in the rooms were also a little fussy. It was very difficult to adjust the thermostat.

It was a beautiful property. High comfort and a feeling of being somewhere special. The staff are friendly and gracious. They cannot do enough to help. Food was exceptional.

No views from the windows but it’s still light and bright. Everything else makes up for it.

Beautiful, spacious rooms, amazing service, excellent location - my new hotel in NY

Everything was impeccable - the food, the service, the room, the cleanliness and bed was the most comfortable I’ve ever slept in! The location is one of the best in the city. What I find to be most impressive is that I have been staying at the The Firmdale properties since 2005 and their quality has never changed - it is still at it’s very best - absolutely outstanding hotels!

Decor Staff is professional , personal and attentive

Only that I couldn’t stay longer:-)